Apple’s iPhone 5 and Why NFC Doesn’t Matter

Today, Apple unveiled the iPhone 5 and, contrary to the expectations of many, it did not include NFC.

As I and others have written previously, NFC doesn’t work for payments because it solves a problem that doesn’t exist. Whenever the topic is raised, though, I get responses saying that people actually think that paying with your phone makes sense. While I may agree with that (to an extent, habits are hard to break) I don’t think that NFC adoption is quick enough to warrant that it, and not internet connection + location services will replace the swipe. That’s what NFC is competing with: taking your card out to swipe it at the POS device.

While NFC is seen in certain retail sectors I strongly believe that it’s merely driven by hardware vendors looking to make more money from a locked in community of merchants; once these have another option (such as the dozens of POS companies out there) they will move. There is no reason to remain with the old device while you can get a fancy Apple device with the latest POS software that will do your analytics for you, and hardware companies understand that (VeriFone and Sail is maybe the latest example). When you look at these trends, betting on NFC seems like a bad idea.

 

2 thoughts on “Apple’s iPhone 5 and Why NFC Doesn’t Matter

  1. Carlos

    Don’t forget we have to change the paradigm. The swipe is gone. NFC is really competing with an EMV card dock. And that is slower than a the swipe and a lot slower than a tap and go. That’s why contactless was introduced by Mass Transit and Quick Service Restaurants.
    And to the point of this being driven by HW vendors, while contactless/NFC do require new hardware that can be bundled-in with the EMV replacement cycle anyway. What we don’t want is go through a terminal replacement AGAIN in 5 years if NFC becomes prevalent. And you already have PEDs out there that support basic non-EMV PayWave/PayPass today anyway…
    Not advocating for it, just bringing up more facts.

    Reply
  2. Ohad Post author

    Thanks for the comment Carlos, I agree that NFC could be positioned in that way too. For my money, I believe adoption will be slow and not relevant for the next wave of payments, and I think the same about EMV.

    Reply

Leave a Reply